PhpBB Mods = Grumpy
Thursday, October 19th, 2006Yesterday, I asked on the phpBB forum if there was any chance XHTML/HTML content negotiation could be added to phpBB. I provided a link to my project as an example. So yeah, some edit-happy mods deleted the link to my project (on the grounds that it was spam … yeah, right) and then locked the thread when I replied again (saying that phpBB 3.0 is feature-frozen … so why wouldn’t the conversation be allowed to move to the subject of the next version?). I realize that phpBB is a big operation, but you would think that they wouldn’t object to someone simply asking for a feature to be added, especially when I’m offering example code. It’s certainly nothing to lock a thread over.
I’m an admin at Fuzziqer Software’s forums, and we never lock a thread unless there’s a flamewar, or something that could get us in trouble legally. So far, I can recall exactly 1 thread that we have locked since the forum was created ages ago. And that was due to a user flaming other users about 4-5 times before we decided that we needed to take action greater than just editing his posts. And he stopped after the thread was locked, and therefore isn’t banned.
Is any forum so big that mods need to lock threads for superficial reasons? I really don’t think so. Seriously, just appoint more mods if you’re having trouble keeping the users in line. The moderators of phpBB: more evidence that too many people just don’t have common decency.